Conspiracy Check

Theories · Pseudolaw

We live in a constitutional republic

"We live in a constitutional republic", "the U.S. is a republic, not a democracy", and variations of these phrases are political slogans associated, since the mid-20th century, with some aspects of conservatism in the United States. Though presented by their proponents as descriptive of the design of the American state since founding, the claims are entirely absent from revolutionary-era writing and commentary, with their earliest recorded appearance dated to 1836. They were catalyzed as popular refrains in the 1960s by candymaker Robert Welch and, after a period of declining usage, reinvigorated in popular commentary around 2010. Scholars agree the assertions do not represent a conventional understanding of comparative politics, American constitutional law, or United States history and may originate in a misunderstanding of political science terminology.

Read the full Wikipedia article ↗ 277 reads in 60 days

Check the claims

Search independent fact-checkers for this topic:

Action items

Prevention steps

  1. StopNotice a strong emotion (anger, fear, 'they don't want you to know') before you share. Pause first.
  2. Investigate the sourceWho is making the claim, what's their expertise, and what do they gain if you believe it?
  3. Find better coverageRead laterally: open new tabs and see what independent outlets and fact-checkers say.
  4. Trace claims to the originFind the original study, video or document. Check dates and whether quotes are cut.
  5. Ask what would change your mindReal theories can be tested. If every piece of counter-evidence 'proves' the cover-up, it can't be.
  6. Count the peopleBig secret plots need thousands of people to stay silent for years. That rarely happens.
  7. Talk, don't mockWith friends or family, ask questions, listen, share your own sources calmly. Shame backfires.
  8. PrebunkLearn the common tricks (cherry-picking, fake experts, false dilemmas) so you spot them early.

Related